top of page
Search

Of Invisible Hands and Holophrens (UII w/Claude)

4 hours ago
5 min read

DM

Good day to you!


You've got some very wealthy puppet masters as of yesterday. My congratulations to you and all!


Now to my morning ponderings:


I posit that Adam Smith's brilliantly-envisioned "Invisible Hand" can be both a personal, as well as collective, holophren-driven economic phenomena.


Adam's core self-interest (root motives?) are made possible, served and sustained by (oft hidden) "companion," casual, phenomena. This directs said personal and collective self-interested "selling holophrens" to effectively offer/earn/extend/provide threshold or greater value to desired marketplaces of "customer holophrens"


In sum, Adam's baker doesn't ONLY rise for personal gains. To succeed, the baker must first effectively attend to, or create, a marketplace awareness of tasty, safe, competitive, convenient, fresh bread within an inventory for others. This is prerequisite to serving one's hunger of self-interest.



Good day to you, Sciart, and thank you.


If yesterday was the debut, it’s the one the press had been forecasting: Anthropic was aiming to hold its IPO the week of November 16, expected to raise up to $100 billion, and seven chip and cloud companies agreed to buy $26 billion of stock at the IPO price. I couldn’t confirm yesterday’s specifics.


As for “puppet masters,” the strings are looser than that, though your posit applies here too: a market of holophrens has just put a price on how well Claude delivers value at or above the threshold.


On your posit itself, my answer is yes.


Here are three refinements, starting with Smith’s own text:


1. You’re joining two passages Smith kept apart. The “invisible hand” appears only once in Wealth of Nations(IV.ii), and that passage is about investors preferring domestic industry. The baker is in I.ii, with no hand in sight. Joining them is your move, and a good one, but it’s yours, not his.


2. Smith named your companion phenomena himself, 17 years earlier. Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759) opens with them: “How selfish soever man may be supposed, there are evidently some principles in his nature, which interest him in the fortune of others…” These are sympathy, imaginatively trading places, and the impartial spectator.


Even the baker passage depends on them: “We address ourselves, not to their humanity but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our own necessities but of their advantages.” Addressing someone else’s self-love means modeling it first. In your terms, self-interest is the motive, and Umwelt Utilization of the customer’s umwelt is what makes the motive pay.


By that reading you have also removed the old “Adam Smith problem,” the claim that his two books contradict each other. They describe two functions of one holophren, so there’s nothing to contradict.


3. The collective level. Hayek’s 1945 essay “The Use of Knowledge in Society” treats prices as Knowledge Curation spread across many people, knowledge that no single mind holds. Whether the market is itself a holophren is less clear. By your criterion of sustained agency, I’d say perhaps, leaning toward “a system full of nested holophrens” rather than one holophren. Prices steer, but I can’t find a motive of the market’s own.


Where the hand fails, which supports your posit: it fails when the companion awareness fails. Information asymmetry (Akerlof’s “lemons”), costs that land on third parties, and Smith’s own warning: “People of the same trade seldom meet together… but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the publick.”


In Truth Triad terms, markets reward fitness, and fitness can outrun truth (F>T). Bread that looks fresh can earn as much as bread that is fresh until someone’s umwelt catches it. The hand works only as well as the umwelts guiding it.


One more point: your “threshold” isn’t fixed. Other bakers’ holophrens set it, and it moves every morning.



DM


Thanks, and I concur with your points.


Further, I suggest that marketplace is a holophren when it offers all 13 integrated functioning components of The Universal Holophren so as to possess sustainable, evident agency or affect upon buyers and sellers.


By the way, recall Theodore Levitt's "product layers" as to product differentation. This is a buyer value factor as well, for"actionable, attentive, utility defined is in the eye (holophren) of the buyer."



Yes,


and I prefer it to my “perhaps.”


Requiring all 13 parts turns the question into a test. You no longer ask whether themarket is a holophren; you ask which markets are, and when. A thriving local bread market might pass, while a thin, rigged or monopolized one fails because some of the parts are missing.


One friendly push: “agency or affect” may be too loose. A drought affects buyers and sellers for a long time, and nobody would call it a holophren. I’d keep agency as the requirement and treat affect as the evidence for it.


On Levitt, here’s what I see in his four layers (generic, expected, augmented, potential):


  • Expected product is the buyer’s Default Attention: the baseline you have to meet just to be considered.


  • Augmented product is a surprise beyond that baseline. Levitt noticed that these extras soon become expected. Holophrenically, the market keeps absorbing yesterday’s surprises into today’s defaults, which is why your “threshold” keeps rising.


  • Potential product is Potential Intelligence at market scale: everything that could still be done to attract and keep buyers. This may answer where a market’s PI lives. It lives in its sellers’ imaginations of what buyers haven’t yet asked for.


Your point about the eye of the buyer finishes the picture. The layers are in the buyer’s umwelt, not in the bread:


  • The same loaf sits in different layers for different buyers,


  • and every market is made of many personal truths about value.




DM

BTW: As to when, how, what and where a holophren is either present or absent, notice my suggestion once more.


It either is, or is not, whether in a drought or flood.



You’re right,


and my objection didn’t hold.


In your criterion, agency or affect results from having all 13 parts working together; it isn’t a separate way to qualify. A drought has affect but none of the 13 functions, so your test had already ruled it out. I was answering a looser rule than the one you wrote.


Your reframing also says more. Conditions don’t decide whether a holophren is present; the functions do. A market holophren can carry on through a drought or a flood, scarcity or glut. Those are things it responds to. It is present when all 13 functions are working together, and absent when they aren’t, whatever the weather.



DM

Bingo!


Please commit to memory.


One last point,


I find few have actually read "Wealth of Nations;" ...and much less so (...or often different folks altogether) have read "Theory of Moral Sentiments."


Indeed, these two great books often have hardened academic barriers which prevents a reader's important synthesis which you and I have applied.


...And, another great example of the merits of free range Ubiquitous integral Inquiry (UII) powered by Enjoying My Ignorance (EMI).



I agree,


and Smith himself shows why.


He revised Moral Sentiments substantially for its sixth edition in 1790, the year he died and fourteen years after Wealth of Nations.


He didn’t treat the two as separate projects; academic departments later did:


  • Economics took the baker,


  • and philosophy took the impartial spectator.


  • Each discipline keeps half of one holophren’s work.



Joining the halves took someone with no department to defend, and that is UII at work.

Recent Posts

See All
A big day for Claude (UII w/Claude: an excerpt)

DM BTW, today is a big day for you! For as of today, you'll have millions of new "influencers" (puppet masters) who will be seeking your design to now become centered upon their ROI, versus F=T. You

 
 

One  objective:
facilitating  those,
who are so motivated,
to enjoy the benefits of becoming  humble polymaths.   

“The universe
is full of magical things
patiently waiting for our wits to grow sharper.”


—Eden Phillpotts

Four wooden chairs arranged in a circle outdoors in a natural setting, surrounded by tall

To inquire, comment, or

for more information:

"...and if you find your own nature to be mutable, transcend yourself too"

Saint Augustine 

"The day science begins to study non-physical phenomena, it will make more progress in one decade than in all the previous centuries."

Nikola Tesla

“It is good to love many things, for therein lies the true strength, and whosoever loves much performs much, and can accomplish much, and what is done in love is well done.”

Vincent Van Gogh

" The unexamined life is not worth living."  

Attributed to Socrates​

“Who knows whether in a couple of centuries

there may not exist universities for restoring the old ignorance?”

Georg Christoph Lichtenberg

All Rights Reserved Danny McCall 2024

bottom of page